WHAT IS EMDR?
EMDR is a psychotherapy developed in the late 1990s specifically for the treatment of chronic pain. When it was created, it looked like an existing behavioral therapy for PTSD, called exposure. Long-term exposure has been and remains the gold standard treatment for PTSD. However, EMDR is a very interesting feature that distinguishes it from extra exposure: the creator claims that by turning a person’s eyes back and forth in a positive way.
Post-traumatic stress disorder. EMDR is usually a repeated description of the patient causing the PTSD problem, all eyes moving back and forth after a metronome, LED light, or other focused object. After several such treatments, the patient is considered less difficult to respond to shock and alleviate the symptoms of PTSD.
Although the author of this treatment, Franchine Shapiro, is not a neurologist and has no formal training in psychology, this statement is very tempting for therapists seeking effective treatment. EMDR quickly became popular among therapists and attracted the attention of researchers, who were excited by the shocking claims about its effectiveness. However, the conclusions of many large-scale EMDR experiments have been the subject of much controversy. For more details contact us click here emdr therapie nebenwirkungen although chronic depression (PTSD) can have health and social effects, there are few controlled studies investigating its treatment.
In this study, a randomized controlled trial was used to compare the effectiveness of two interventions in the treatment of PTSD psychosis. Thirty veterans diagnosed with PTSD-related diseases received (a) 12 blind exercise and resuscitation courses, EMDR (n = 10), (b) 12 biofeedback relaxation courses (n = 13), or (c) health care Routine, as a control (n = 12).
Compared with other situations, after many self-report, psychological and standard interview measures, a significant therapeutic effect of EMDR was found in the treatment. Compared with other treatment groups, this effect was generally maintained during the 3-month follow-up period. Psychological intervention reflects the cultural influence from treatment to reprocessing, but it does not differ depending on the treatment status.
DOES IT WORK?
So is EMDR effective? The short answer is yes… buddy. Researchers have found that EMDR is significantly more effective than placebo in reducing the symptoms of PTSD, and in most patients who complete the entire course of treatment; it can effectively reduce symptoms (Carlson et al., 1998).
As a result, EMDR caught fire and was quickly taken over by the Veterans Administration due to its effective research. It has become an evidence-based alternative therapy, providing therapists with more options for treating PTSD patients.
But there is a catch. A psychiatrist with experience in cognitive behavioral therapy, further introduction, has identified many elements of the new therapy. The only difference they saw was the inclusion of eye movement characteristics, which are properties defined by EMDR. After the flood of active research, another wave of EMDR research was published, but this time the research is destroying the analysis, and the research is testing the most effective therapeutic ingredients.
Although EMDR was found to be an effective treatment for PTSD when the eye movement component was excluded from the treatment, the results were similar. Several important studies conducted (ie, Davidson and Parker, 2001) found the same thing: eye movements do not add anything to the treatment (except for the additional cost of the therapist). It is just a treatment of the nature of cognitive science knowledge. In addition, the following study compared patient results between EMDR and outpatient results and found no differences.
SHOULD I TRY THIS THERAPY?
The good news is that since research shows that EMDR is unlikely to work differently from the extended way, it is still beneficial to patients who receive it. The problem is that despite the discovery of additional, unnecessary ingredients, this processing continues. EMDR does not seem to be one of the most advanced treatments, nor does it use the best psychological science it provides.
Emphasis on proven practice, becoming a popular treatment technique shows the number of clinics based on a large number of unsupported research and strong cultural activities. 83% of doctors do not use exposure therapy (Zayfert et al., 2005). Due to its high success rate, exposure therapy is the preferred treatment for all anxiety disorders. These worrying statistics emphasize the importance of patients who need to be experienced clients, asking about their treatment methods and training before they are considered patients.
However, what is even more worrying is that in recent years, therapists have reported that EMDR can effectively treat everything from major depression to schizophrenia. These allegations simply do not support the investigation. The only treatment that EMDR has proven to be more effective than traditional speech therapy is PTSD. Any other statements by EMDR doctors are not based on any research or further scientific research on the subject.